back arrow icon
Back

C-Corp vs LLC: What's the right structure for your startup?

Discover the key differences between C-Corps and LLC. Choose the right structure for your startup!
Legal
October 20, 2024
|
5 min.

As a startup founder, you're already used to making tough decisions, but few are as critical—or as confusing—as choosing the right business structure. Whether you're an international founder looking to break into the U.S. market or you're planning your startup's long-term growth, the decision between forming a C-Corp or an LLC can shape the future of your company.

Incorporating your business isn’t just about paperwork—it’s about strategy. The right structure affects everything from how you pay taxes to how you raise funds, and even how you attract top talent. So, how do you know which one is right for you? In this post, we’ll break down the key differences between a C-Corp and an LLC, and guide you through the decision-making process based on your startup’s unique goals.

Whether you’re eyeing rapid growth and venture capital or aiming for simplicity and flexibility, this guide will help you make an informed choice so your startup can hit the ground running.

Key considerations for choosing a business structure

1. Tax Implications

Your business structure will directly impact how you’re taxed. Are you prepared to deal with corporate tax rates or would you prefer the simplicity of pass-through taxation (we explain this later)?

2. Fundraising Potential

If you’re planning to raise venture capital, investors may strongly favor one structure over another. Knowing this in advance helps align your company’s long-term strategy.

3. Operational Flexibility

Different structures offer varying levels of flexibility regarding management and ownership. It’s important to consider how much control and administrative burden you’re willing to take on.

4. Investor Preferences

Startups are risky enough for investors to risk on an unfamiliar business structure. C-Corps tend to be the standard for venture capital firms, while LLCs might be less attractive for institutional investors but more flexible for smaller investors or bootstrapped companies. But nothing is set in stone, and there's no 1-way to be a startup!

Schedule a free call

What is a C-Corporation (C-Corp)?

A C-Corp is a legal entity that exists separately from its owners (shareholders) and, therefore, is taxed separately from them. 

It’s one of the most popular business structures for startups looking to grow quickly, particularly through venture capital or by going public. 

Key aspects of a C-Corporation:

  • Double Taxation: One of the key aspects of a C-Corp is that the corporation itself pays taxes on its profits, and then shareholders are taxed again when they receive dividends. This “double taxation” is a downside for many.
  • Compliance and Formalities: C-Corps require strict governance, including regular board meetings, shareholder meetings, and annual filings. While this adds complexity, it also provides a clear structure that can instill confidence in investors.
  • Raising Venture Capital: If your goal is to raise multiple rounds of capital, most investors will expect your company to be a C-Corp. This structure allows for issuing stock options, which are a key tool in attracting talent.

What is a Limited Liability Company (LLC)?

An LLC is a flexible business structure that combines the limited liability features of a corporation with the tax efficiencies and operational flexibility of a partnership.

Key aspects of an LLC:

  • Pass-Through Taxation: Unlike a C-Corp, LLCs do not pay corporate taxes. Instead, profits and losses are reported on the personal tax returns of the owners (members). This can lead to significant tax savings, especially for smaller or bootstrapped startups.
  • Simplified Compliance: LLCs are much easier to manage compared to C-Corps. They don’t have the same level of formal governance and can operate with more flexibility in how the business is structured and managed.
  • Flexibility for Smaller Businesses: If you’re not looking for venture capital or don’t plan to scale quickly, the LLC structure offers a lot of freedom in terms of management and taxation, making it a great option for early-stage startups.

Key differences between C-Corps and LLCs

Schedule a free call

When to choose a C-Corp over an LLC?

If you’re building a fast-growing startup and plan to raise significant amounts of capital, a C-Corp may be the best choice for you. 

Here are a few situations where a C-Corp would be the recommended structure:

  • You plan to raise venture capital: If your startup aims to raise money from institutional investors or venture capital firms, most will require a C-Corp structure.
  • You want to offer stock options: Stock options can be an effective way to attract and retain talent. Offering equity through stock options is more straightforward in a C-Corp.
  • You’re targeting an IPO: For startups with big ambitions to go public, a C-Corp is usually the best structure to accommodate that goal.

Quick Questionnaire for Founders:

If you answer “yes” to most of these questions, a C-Corp may be the right choice for your startup.

When to choose an LLC Over a C-Corp

An LLC can be a great option if you are focused on flexibility, tax savings, and want to keep things simple. 

Consider an LLC if:

  • You are bootstrapping: If your startup is self-funded or backed by a small group of investors (friends and family), an LLC offers the flexibility you need.
  • You want to minimize taxes: LLCs offer pass-through taxation, meaning your business income is taxed at your personal income tax rate, avoiding corporate taxes.
  • You’re looking for simplicity: LLCs come with fewer formalities and governance requirements, making them easier and cheaper to manage.

Quick Questionnaire for Founders:

If most of your answers are “yes” here, an LLC might be the best structure for your business.

Schedule a free call

Special Considerations for Latino Founders

Many Latin American founders seeking to incorporate in the U.S. face unique challenges due to differences in local tax laws, investor expectations, and the nature of their operations. When deciding between a C-Corp and an LLC, latino founders should consider the following:

1. Tax Optimization

If your startup’s primary operations are in Latin America but you need a U.S. legal entity for investments, an LLC might be more beneficial. With an LLC, you avoid double taxation in the U.S. and can still operate tax-efficiently in your home country.

2. Venture Capital Concerns

Many investors, especially U.S.-based venture capitalists, prefer investing in C-Corps. However, if your startup is still small or self-funded, starting with an LLC may offer more flexibility. You can convert to a C-Corp later when the time is right.

3. Cayman Sandwich Structure

Some Latin American startups opt for a tax-optimized structure known as the "Cayman Sandwich." This involves setting up a holding company in the Cayman Islands, which offers tax advantages for international operations and eventual fundraising. It allows startups to maintain a local structure while using a C-Corp as the U.S. entity for receiving investments.

Latam Startup Checklist

Answer these questions to assess whether an LLC or C-Corp fits your U.S. incorporation needs as a Latin American founder:

If you answered “Yes” to most questions: An LLC might be the better choice for flexibility, tax savings, and simplicity, especially if your operations are primarily in Latin America.

If you answered “No” to most questions: A C-Corp could be a better fit, especially if you’re targeting institutional investors or planning to scale rapidly with international expansion.

So, which structure is right for your startup?

Deciding between a C-Corp and an LLC depends on your startup’s long-term goals. If you plan on raising capital, offering stock options, or going public, a C-Corp is often the best path. However, if you prefer operational flexibility, tax simplicity, and want to maintain full control over your business in the early stages, an LLC might be more suitable. At Lazo, we can help guide you through this decision-making process to ensure your business is structured for success.

Schedule a free call

Legal Disclaimer:

⚠️Important: This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified legal or financial professional to determine the best structure for your specific business needs.